France in the Second
World War
The Sorrow and the Pity
Xan Brooks
Friday May 21, 2004
The Guardian
The Nazi occupation of France
lasted more than four years. Marcel Ophuls' landmark 1969 documentary boils
it down to a more manageable 265 minutes - which still amounts to an awful
lot of sorrow and a veritable ocean of pity. Strange to note, then, that the
film is so boldly conceived, richly textured and beautifully paced that its
marathon running time feels more like a sprint.
The Sorrow and the Pity alights
in the town of Clermont-Ferrand, 20 miles from Vichy and a microcosm, one
imagines, of occupied France in general. Employing a seamless blend of
contemporary interviews, newsreel footage and propaganda films, it paints an
engrossing portrait of a cowed and compromised nation, presided over by the
Blimpish Marshal Pétain and serenaded by the honeyed tones of Maurice
Chevalier.
The opening section is as
apocalyptic as any sci-fi thriller. The Maginot Line breaks and France goes
under. We see the roads clogged with lines of abandoned getaway cars while a
triumphant Hitler plays tourist around a deserted Paris. Before long,
collaboration has become the norm. A hairdresser casually shops her friend
to the Gestapo. A Nazi aristocrat recalls the decadent nightlife. A
shopkeeper named Klein takes out an ad in the local paper to assure his
customers he's not Jewish. Interviewed three decades later, these people
squirm and dissemble and justify their behaviour with airy hand gestures and
nervous glances to the corner.
The Sorrow and the Pity was
originally made for French television, except that the authorities refused
to show it. You can see what they objected to. Ophuls' revisionist history
lesson effectively exploded the myth of Vichy France as some hotbed of
patriotic fervour, with De Gaullists camped out in every barn. In its place
it revealed a country caught hopelessly off guard and then sold down the
river by its own middle class.
"The workers always showed more
resistance," explains one old-timer. "But the bourgeoisie were scared. They
had more to lose." When asked for his abiding memory of the occupation, one
silver-haired bourgeois recalls the splendid hunting season of 1942. The
woods, he says, were absolutely teeming with game.
In the film's second half, the
Resistance sparks into life around Clermont-Ferrand and heroes belatedly
emerge from the rubble. When set against the context that Ophuls has
established, their actions look all the more remarkable. We meet Gaspar, the
bull-necked boss of the local Maquis, obviously still enraged by the
compliance of his neighbours. We follow the fortunes of Pierre
Mendès-France, a mercurial Jewish politician who broke out of his prison
cell, and the wonderfully named Dennis Rake, a gay British operative
determined to prove that he was as brave as any heterosexual.
Finally, waiting in the wings,
are those faceless students from Clermont-Ferrand high school, who joined
the Resistance and are no longer around to tell the tale. "Many of them have
streets named after them now," boasts their proud former teacher - who stood
by and did nothing.